Today I read a headline that said “75% Probability Apple Stays With AT&T”. That was based on: “"couldn’t find compelling evidence" that AT&T's contract with Apple ends this year. He gives it a 50% chance. Additionally, there's a 25% chance that AT&T would bid for  and win  another year of exclusivity. Add them up, you get 75%”.
Whenever somebody adds up probabilities, that sets off an alarm in my head. What if the analyst believed that there was a 60% probability that AT&T would get the new contract? Then the sum of the probabilities would be 110%. That’s a little more than absolute certainty, which never exists in the stock market.
The lesson here is to use a little, what I will call, “senseitivity analysis”. Plug some plausible numbers in to make sure that the answer still passes a common sense test. We know that the probability must be 100% or less. In this case, it will certainly be less than 100%. So the result of 110% tells us that there is a math problem here. Doing a little “senseitivity analysis” is a good idea in simulation models as well as the stock market.
For the record, the correct answer is 62.5%. I will let you work out the math.
Thursday, February 4, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Popular Posts

I taught a oneonone ExtendSim class a few weeks ago. The student asked about ONLINE resources a new modeler should be aware of. Gr...

Since the late 1990s, ExtendSim has had an embedded database as part of its simulation tool. Now in its second generation, it is so incredi...

I worked on a simulation study last year with Dr. Holt (University of Washington) and Dr. Srinivasan (University of Tennessee). The results ...

Animation is an important feature of a simulation model. And it’s a great way to introduce a model to someone who has never seen a simul...

I recently had a discussion with a scheduler at a manufacturing plant. I was trying to explain to him the benefits of simulation, and I thou...

The other day, I was talking to a fellow ExtendSim model developer, Aaron Kim from JWA Consulting. Aaron, who is a Lean consultant i...

Over the last 10 years , more than a thousand students have attended one or more of my simulation classes. I have seen successful and not...